Over the years I’ve heard a lot of pros and cons of coffee. Some people believe that caffeine is helpful to overall health and wellness. Other people think it can severely hinder efforts to lose weight and get healthy from the inside out.
I did some research on the topic to see if I could convince myself one way or the other about whether or not to cut caffeine from my daily routine. But guess what—I’m still just as confused as ever! Instead of making an argument for either side, I’m just going to share some pros and cons with you and so you can decide if caffeine has a place in your life.
P.S. I’m totally drinking a soy latte right now…so take that as you will.
Why You Should Drink Caffeine
There seem to be a lot of medical and weight loss articles boasting about the positive effects of caffeine on the body. In an article on Authority Nutrition, Aline Petre, MS, RD wrote that caffeine can improve brain function and blocks signals to molecules like adenosine, which can negatively affect the way you feel. Some people even say that caffeine helps them think clearly and stay focused throughout the day.
In this same article, Petre also argues that caffeine can help increase a person’s metabolism, which helps the body burn more calories in a day. It can also prevent quick muscle fatigue so you can go harder in the gym. This is why most pre-workout supplements contain caffeine.
As far as health benefits, many experts agree that a certain amount of caffeine can improve body function while lowering the risk for certain diseases. Sara Altshul of The Huffington Post points out that some studies have shown that caffeine could lower the risk for skin cancer, stroke, and heart conditions.
Why You Should Think About that Next Cup of Joe
Before you head on a rampage to your local coffee shop and order the biggest, most sugar-filled drink on the menu, take note that too much caffeine can have really adverse effects on your whole body.
First of all, adding a lot of sugar and creamer to a drink will throw your blood sugar for a loop. Ideally, your blood sugar is supposed to stay pretty neutral throughout the day. If you go too long without eating, your blood sugar takes a dive. If you eat too many carbs or too much sugar, it soars. These drastic changes are not good for your body, which is designed to survive in an environment that does not have grocery stores and fast food joints standing on every corner. Once your blood sugar is out of whack, your body devotes a lot of time and energy to stabilizing it, which can throw off other parts of your system. A grande caramel macchiato has 33 grams of sugar in it. Men are supposed to have 37.5 grams of sugar and women are supposed to have 25 grams in an entire day! I know this is not directly related to caffeine, but most people I know choose a flavored coffee drink over a cup of straight black java.
Alisa Vitti is a functional nutritionist and women’s hormone expert who cured her PCOS naturally with food. She believes that caffeine in any form is detrimental to women, especially those who already have hormonal issues. Men can metabolize caffeine faster than women and their bodies get rid of fluids faster than ours do. Since the female body is designed to grow another human being, we have some safety measures that affect other parts of our lives. We hold onto fluids longer and do not metabolize them quickly. This gives caffeine the chance to affect our sleep cycles, wreak havoc on our adrenal system, and really mess with our hormones. Vitti does not think women should have caffeine in any form, but women with PCOS should definitely stay away from it.
Too much caffeine also increases the risk for insomnia and irritability. It might upset your stomach or noticeably increase your heart rate. It might also interact badly with certain medications. Let your doctor know if you are a big coffee drinker before taking any prescriptions.
The Choice is Yours
Some people metabolize caffeine better than others and do not experience any negative effects from it. Other people (like me) can’t have more than one cup a day without feeling jittery. If you do not feel like you can live without your daily caffeine fix, I’m definitely not telling you to ditch your morning brew. If you do drink caffeine, though, the Mayo Clinic recommends that you have no more than 400 milligrams (4 cups of brewed coffee) per day.
I personally have never been a big coffee drinker and I can easily go a day without it. Since it seems to have such a big impact on me, I might try to switch to herbal tea for a few weeks to see what happens. I’ll keep you guys posted!